top of page

Prisons Are Overcrowded And Expensive For Governments To Maintain - IELTS Band 9 Essay

In many places, prisons are overcrowded and expensive for governments to maintain. Yet, when offenders are released, they end up back in prison a short while later - IELTS Band 9 Essay

Get your personalised IELTS Essay Feedback from a former examiner

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score

Model Essay 1

The debate surrounding the effectiveness of prisons and the optimal approach to handling lawbreakers - whether through rehabilitation or punishment - remains pivotal in justice systems worldwide. This essay argues that while prisons fail to fully rehabilitate offenders, as evidenced by high recidivism rates, a balanced approach that tailors responses based on the severity of crimes offers a more effective solution, blending protective measures with opportunities for rehabilitation.

Prisons are designed to deter criminal activities and protect the public, yet the persistently high rates of recidivism call into question their effectiveness. Studies reveal that over 60% of released prisoners in the United States reoffend within three years, highlighting a systemic failure where mere confinement does little to address the root causes of criminal behaviour. This alarming statistic casts doubt on the capacity of prisons to function as rehabilitative institutions and suggests a pressing need for a reevaluation of their role in the justice system. Recognizing this issue, it becomes evident that a differentiated approach based on the severity and nature of the crime could offer a more effective solution.

The approach to handling offenders should be guided by the nature of the crime and the individual's background, balancing rehabilitation and punishment. For minor offenses like theft or drug possession, rehabilitation through educational programs, counselling, and skill development has proven to yield better outcomes, as evidenced by the Scandinavian prison model which emphasizes rehabilitation and reports some of the lowest recidivism rates globally. However, for severe crimes such as murder or sexual assault, a stricter approach is necessary to ensure public safety, yet this does not eliminate the possibility of rehabilitation. A case-by-case assessment, rigorous psychological evaluations, and tailored rehabilitation plans are crucial in determining the potential for reform, even among those who have committed heinous crimes.

In conclusion, while prisons do not entirely succeed as rehabilitative institutions, abandoning the concept of reformative justice is not advisable. The dichotomy between rehabilitation and punishment is not absolute. A balanced approach, sensitive to the nature of the crime and the individual's potential for change, can lead to a more effective justice system.

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score

Model Essay 2

The persistent overcrowding and high maintenance costs of prisons, coupled with the high recidivism rates post-release, raise critical questions about their effectiveness. This essay argues that while punishment is necessary, it must be strategically combined with rehabilitation to mitigate these issues, focusing primarily on reducing recidivism and optimizing corrections spending.

The first point of discussion is the current inefficacy of prisons as purely punitive institutions. Numerous studies, such as those conducted by the Bureau of Justice Statistics in the United States, show that over 60% of released prisoners are rearrested within three years. This high recidivism rate not only underscores the failure of prisons to deter future crimes but also reflects the inadequate provision of rehabilitative services. For instance, rehabilitation programs, when implemented effectively, have been shown to significantly reduce reoffense rates. However, the lack of such programs within many prison systems worldwide suggests a missed opportunity to enhance societal safety and offender reintegration. Enhanced rehabilitative strategies could transform prisons into facilities that not only penalize but also educate and heal, thus addressing the root causes of criminal behaviour.

Moreover, the economic impact of maintaining high recidivism rates is substantial, with billions spent annually to house returning offenders. A more rehabilitative approach, exemplified by the Norwegian prison system, which incorporates extensive vocational training and mental health support, demonstrates a lower recidivism rate and reduced long-term costs to taxpayers. This model supports the idea that investment in comprehensive rehabilitation programs, tailored to individual offender needs, can be economically beneficial and socially responsible. Such programs not only prepare inmates for a successful reentry into society but also reduce the likelihood of future incarcerations. By investing in these rehabilitative measures, governments can ultimately decrease the financial burden of repeat incarcerations and foster a safer, more productive community environment.

In conclusion, while the punitive aspect of imprisonment is necessary to maintain law and order, its effectiveness is significantly enhanced when paired with robust rehabilitation strategies. By shifting focus from mere containment to active rehabilitation, prisons can fulfill their role more effectively, offering both a deterrent to crime and a pathway to a productive life post-release.

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score

Model Essay 3

The question of whether prisons are an effective measure for deterring crime and managing offenders is a complex one, sparking extensive debate. This essay contends that while prisons do play a crucial role in public safety, they are insufficient on their own in preventing reoffensive behaviours without significant reforms focusing on rehabilitation.

Firstly, the primary purpose of incarceration is to deter criminal behaviour and provide a sense of justice to society. However, evidence suggests that simply detaining individuals without addressing underlying issues or providing support for reintegration leads to high recidivism rates. For example, in many jurisdictions where punitive measures are prioritized over rehabilitative efforts, more than half of the inmates return to prison within three years of release. This highlights the ineffectiveness of a solely punitive approach and underscores the necessity for programs that address mental health, addiction, and educational deficiencies among the incarcerated population.

Secondly, the nature of the crime and the individual's history should dictate the corrective strategy employed. Minor and non-violent offenders often benefit significantly from rehabilitation programs that include vocational training, therapy, and continued support after release. Countries like Norway have implemented such systems, resulting in notably low recidivism rates and better societal reintegration. Conversely, for serious offenses such as violent crimes, a more nuanced approach is required. While these offenders may also benefit from rehabilitative programs, the primary focus should remain on public safety, possibly extending incarceration times or integrating high-security rehabilitation facilities.

In conclusion, while prisons are essential for maintaining public safety, their current operational models in many regions fail to prevent reoffending. A reformative approach, tailored to the severity of the crime and the specific needs of the offender, is necessary to truly enhance the effectiveness of the criminal justice system.

Get your personalised IELTS Essay Feedback from a former examiner

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score



Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page