To Protect Local Culture, Tourism Should be Banned in Some Areas, or Banning Tourism will have no Benefits? - IELTS Essay

Get your personalised IELTS Essay Feedback from a former examiner

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score

Model Essay 1

The debate surrounding tourism and its impact on local culture presents a conundrum: while some advocate for restrictions to preserve cultural integrity, others argue that change is a natural progression, rendering such bans futile. This essay contends that while protective measures are essential, they should be balanced to foster cultural exchange and economic development.

Opponents of tourism argue that it frequently leads to the dilution of local traditions, as cultural practices are commodified to meet tourist expectations. For instance, at various historical landmarks, traditional ceremonies are often transformed into mere spectacles for visitors, thus eroding their authentic cultural significance. This perspective emphasizes the need for stringent regulations or even prohibitions on tourism in particularly sensitive regions to protect the authenticity of local cultures. Advocates of this stance are convinced that such preventive measures are indispensable for maintaining the unique cultural identities of communities in an increasingly globalized world, thereby preventing the complete assimilation into a homogenized culture.

On the other hand, proponents of tourism argue that cultural exchange is not only inevitable but also immensely beneficial. They posit that being exposed to diverse cultures promotes a deeper understanding and appreciation, potentially leading to the reinforcement and preservation of cultural heritage, rather than its degradation. Furthermore, tourism acts as a vital economic engine, providing substantial income and creating numerous employment opportunities for local communities, thus contributing to their sustainable development. The example of Bhutan serves as an ideal model, demonstrating how controlled tourism practices can result in significant economic advantages without sacrificing the country’s cultural integrity. This approach highlights tourism’s capability to positively influence both economic growth and the conservation of cultural heritage, assuming it is implemented with careful consideration and respect for the local environment and traditions.

In conclusion, while the protection of local culture is paramount, outright bans on tourism might not be the most effective strategy. A nuanced approach, recognizing the benefits of cultural exchange and economic development, offers a more sustainable path forward. By embracing controlled and respectful tourism, we can ensure the protection of cultural heritage while benefiting from the global interconnectedness it brings.

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score

Model Essay 2

The discourse on the intersection of tourism and local culture is polarized, with one camp arguing for stringent measures to protect cultural sanctity, while the other heralds tourism as a catalyst for cultural exchange and economic growth. This essay posits that an equilibrium between conservation and openness can preserve cultural identities while embracing the benefits of globalization.

Critics of unrestricted tourism contend that it dilutes local cultures, transforming sacred traditions into tourist attractions. This commodification, they argue, undermines the authenticity of cultural expressions and rituals, making them performative rather than genuine. For example, in many indigenous communities, rituals and dances with deep spiritual significance are often repackaged for entertainment, losing their original context and meaning. This viewpoint underscores the importance of imposing limitations on tourism in culturally sensitive areas to prevent the erosion of distinct cultural identities, suggesting that such protective measures are vital for communities to maintain their heritage in the global village.

In contrast, tourism advocates argue that interaction between cultures is both inevitable and beneficial, promoting mutual respect and understanding. They highlight tourism’s role as an economic lifeline, generating revenue and employment for locals. Through the lens of sustainable tourism, practices can be designed to both celebrate and preserve cultural heritage while fostering economic development. The strategy employed by countries like Japan, where cultural sites and practices are thoughtfully integrated into the tourism experience, showcases how tourism can enhance cultural appreciation without compromising authenticity. This perspective emphasizes the potential of well-managed tourism to serve as a bridge between economic advancement and cultural preservation.

In conclusion, while the protection of cultural integrity is paramount, an outright ban on tourism is not the sole solution. A balanced approach, encouraging responsible tourism that respects and uplifts local cultures, can forge a path toward sustainable development. Cultivating an environment where cultural heritage thrives alongside tourism requires innovative policies that prioritize both preservation and progress.

Get your personalised IELTS Essay Feedback from a former examiner

Download IELTS eBooks, get everything you need to achieve a high band score